Sho Kosugi > Chuck Norris
There, I said it. People may not like it, but that's only because Sho Kosugi wants you to believe otherwise.
I experienced my first ninjas through Ninja 3: The Domination. It was not only martial artsy, but folded in a mystical element that made ninjas special to me from that point on. I also learned that "Only a ninja can destroy a ninja."
I loved the way that Ninja Assassin took ninja mysticism to a new level. Now, ninjas can heal themselves with mind over body techniques. Now, they no longer need smokescreens to disappear, but disappear into smoke. Their physical prowess is unmatched. They do not fear. They do not feel. They exist only to serve the 9 clans. In all things they are to bring honor to their creator, the one who has given them their lives as a gift...yes, Sho Kosugi.
Visually, the film is stunning. Ninjas come out of the shadow. Acrobatics abounds. They have numerous scars, even from training, which expresses history and intensity during the quiet scenes.
And how was the story? I thought very good for a ninja movie. Unfortunately, we seem to be trapped into a "revenge" narrative, which is the norm. I would have liked to see more in protagonist motivation. And, I wasn't thrilled with the whole bringing in the marines thing at the end, a scene in which ninjas who formerly walked all over the military couldn't hear them drive up in their big trucks before they started gunning them down. I mean, really? Still, we're watching a ninja movie, and quality story isn't the primary concern of those watching, so I'm not surprised. In fact, it was better than expected.
My overall rating: 7/10. That means I loved this movie. I'm glad I saw it, and I would have liked to have seen it in the theatre (which is a big thing for me since tickets are about $10 now). With an improved story, it could have easily reached an 8.
Btw, my scale:
1-3: crash and burn, don't waste your money, I'll never get that time back
4-6: no regrets, not worth theatre costs though, I was amused
7-9: loved it, worth the theatre costs, worth watching again on DVD
10: ZOMG, Pan's Labyrinth!